Tuesday, December 18, 2012

Wal-Mart in Mexico: It's Not Getting Better

Back in April, the New York Times published a devastating article by David Barstow about bribery at Wal-Mart de Mexico. And while some Times readers were inclined to give the company a free pass ("This is apparently the method of doing business in Mexico..."), I argued that this argument (a) painted a whole country with a very big brush, and (b) ignored the inconvenient fact that bribery is illegal in both the U.S. and Mexico. The behavior uncovered was, in addition, a complete violation of Wal-Mart's own code of ethics (the first of which is, "Always act with integrity.").

Today's Times has another compelling, worth-reading-in-full story by Barstow and Alejandra Xanic von Bertrab on how Wal-Mart systematically used bribes to get what it wanted and grow its business in Mexico.
The Times’s examination reveals that Wal-Mart de Mexico was not the reluctant victim of a corrupt culture that insisted on bribes as the cost of doing business. Nor did it pay bribes merely to speed up routine approvals. Rather, Wal-Mart de Mexico was an aggressive and creative corrupter, offering large payoffs to get what the law otherwise prohibited. It used bribes to subvert democratic governance — public votes, open debates, transparent procedures. It used bribes to circumvent regulatory safeguards that protect Mexican citizens from unsafe construction. It used bribes to outflank rivals. 

The Times investigation found 19 store sites in Mexico where the trail of bribes matched up with a trail of permits. For example: "Thanks to nine bribe payments totaling $765,000, Wal-Mart built a vast refrigerated distribution center in an environmentally fragile flood basin north of Mexico City, in an area where electricity was so scarce that many smaller developers were turned away." Wal-Mart is the largest private employer in Mexico.

According to the article, Wal-Mart de Mexico employees did not themselves deliver bribe payments, but entrusted "fixers" to deliver payoffs:
Wal-Mart de Mexico’s written policies said these fixers could be entrusted with up to $280,000 to “expedite” a single permit. The bribe payments covered the payoffs themselves, a commission for the fixer and taxes. For some permits, it was left to the fixers to figure out who needed to be bribed.  

How much did Bentonville, Arkansas, Wal-Mart's global headquarters know? It's hard to be sure, at least without a full judicial investigation. The Times quotes a Wal-Mart spokesperson as saying, "We are committed to having a strong and effective global anticorruption program everywhere we operate and taking appropriate action for any instance of noncompliance," and notes that the company has spent more than $100 million on investigative costs related to anticorruption training and background checks this year. Given that the company relies on careful financial accounting for its success, I do find it hard to believe that headquarters was unaware.

I wasn't surprised by the revelations back in April, and I'm not surprised now. Disappointed, oh yes.



Friday, December 7, 2012

It's Not the New Year Yet, But I Have a Resolution

I'm getting tired of writing posts in the aftermath of a horrific garment-factory fire. I wrote two in September (here and here), following the worst factory fire in Pakistan's history (one of several New York Times reports, here). And late last month there was another tragic fire, in Bangladesh.

New York Times reporter Vikas Bajaj wrote that "Bangladesh’s garment industry, the second-largest exporter of clothing after China, has a notoriously poor fire safety record. Since 2006, more than 500 Bangladeshi workers have died in factory fires..." Worse, many of the deaths were preventable, if proper -- or indeed any -- precautions had been taken. In the late November fire, another 112 workers were killed.

I hadn't thought about writing about this issue again. After all, how many times can I make a case for really tough regulations? But the story won't let go of me. Because I know I bear some responsibility too. I read labels (I hate paying for dry-cleaning, so I always look for washing instructions). I note, in passing, where a particular item was made or assembled. But do I go further than that? No.

It had been reported that the factory, Tazreen Fashions, made clothes for a number of Western companies, including Walmart / Sam's Club, Sears, and others.

In the first days after the fire, Walmart issued a statement saying,
While we are trying to determine if the factory has a current relationship with Walmart or one of our suppliers, fire safety is a critically important area of Walmart’s factory audit program and we have been working across the apparel industry to improve fire safety education and training in Bangladesh.
In yesterday's Times, Steven Greenhouse reported that documents had been found in the factory's rubble that confirm that about one-third of the production lines were devoted to Walmart / Sam's Club products. Of even greater concern, the report stated that
In a related matter, two officials who attended a meeting held in Bangladesh in 2011 to discuss factory safety in the garment industry said on Wednesday that the Walmart official there played the lead role in blocking an effort to have global retailers pay more for apparel to help Bangladesh factories improve their electrical and fire safety.....

According to the minutes of the meeting, which were made available to The Times, Sridevi Kalavakolanu, a Walmart director of ethical sourcing, along with an official from another major apparel retailer, noted that the proposed improvements in electrical and fire safety would involve as many as 4,500 factories and would be "in most cases" a "very extensive and costly modification."

"It is not financially feasible for the brands to make such investments," the minutes said. 

Kevin Gardner, a Walmart spokesman, said the company official’s remarks in Bangladesh were "out of context."
It's hard for me to imagine the context in which those comments, from a "director of ethical sourcing", would be acceptable.

Of course Walmart will do everything possible to squeeze costs from its supply chain. How else can it promise "Save money. Live better."? 

But I don't think I am the only American who would pay a few pennies more for a T-shirt that didn't smell like smoke and sound like screams.

In today's Times, Jim Yardley tries to sift through the data to find how Tazreen, a factory whose "bosses had been faulted for violations during inspections conducted on behalf of Walmart and at the behest of the Business Social Compliance Initiative, a European organization", and still managed to continue receiving orders from major companies, "slipping through the gaps in the system by delivering the low costs and quick turnarounds that buyers — and consumers — demand." (Yardley's full story, worth reading in its depressing entirety, is here)

Who bears the ultimate responsibility? We all do.

Yardley quotes Richard Locke, deputy dean of MIT's Sloan School of Management: "We as consumers like to be able to buy ever-greater quantities of ever-cheaper goods, every year.Somebody is bearing the cost of it, and we don’t want to know about it. The people bearing the cost were in this fire."

Many of the victims were young women, drawn from rural Bangladeshi villages to the outskirts of Dhaka, lured by the promise of good wages: $45 a month. (And yes, even in Bangladesh, that's not much to live on.)

Today, both Walmart and Sears are saying that Tazreen was not an authorized supplier. But it's not that simple. Yardley spoke with David Hasanat of the Viyellatex Group, "one of the country's most highly regarded garment manufacturers" who noted that
...that global apparel retailers often depend on hundreds of factories to fill orders. Given the scale of work, retailers frequently place orders through suppliers and other middlemen who, in turn, steer work to factories that deliver low costs — a practice he said is hardly unknown to Western retailers and clothing brands. The order for Walmart’s Faded Glory shorts [being produced at Tazreen at the time of the fire], documents show, was subcontracted from Simco Bangladesh Ltd., a local garment maker. "It is an open secret to allow factories to do that," Mr. Hasanat said. "End of the day, for them it is the price that matters." 
In other words, for the retailers, if they have plausible deniability, that's all that matters.

Corporations won't care until we consumers show that we care.

Ask questions before you buy. Buy from companies and countries in which workers have real rights and regulations have real teeth. If that means each item costs more, buy fewer items.

That's my resolution for the New Year, and I hope you'll join me.

Tuesday, December 4, 2012

Sadly, We Do Have a Trifecta Winner

The results are now in, and Wet Seal is indeed a trifecta winner: Illegal, Immoral, and Stupid.

What?

Back in July, the New York Times and other media outlets reported that Wet Seal, a retailer of "fast fashion" apparel for young women, was being sued by former employees because "the company had a high-level policy of firing and denying pay increases and promotions to African-American employees because they did not fit its 'brand image.'" (Original Times story, by Steven Greenhouse, here)

To be honest, I found it hard to believe that a nationwide retailer could be that, well, stupid. Racial discrimination is both immoral and illegal, and to have a policy in place like this seemed unlikely.

At least that's what I hoped. So I coupled my comments on Wet Seal with a report on some recent research that suggests that fast ethical decisions are worse than slow, thoughtful ones. Perhaps, I wrote, the problem was the Wet Seal was just reacting too fast to, for example, slumping sales at a particular store -- let's just fire the frontline staff and store manager, and maybe that will fix the problem. They just didn't think the situation through, right? (Original blog post, here)

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has now found in favor of the plaintiffs, ruling in a "determination" that Wet Seal's managers had made it overtly clear that they wanted employees who had the "Armani look, were white, had blue eyes, thin and blond in order to be profitable." (as reported, again by Steven Greenhouse, in today's Times; full story, here)

The federal commission said that, prior to the forcing-out of one of the African-American women plaintiffs, "she had received high ratings in running the King of Prussia [PA] store, which was ranked No. 8 among Wet Seal's more than 500 stores. Her regional manager and district manager had said she had 'great energy' and 'strong ability' to hold other managers and subordinates accountable in fulfilling their responsibilities." These attributes, however, were apparently not enough for senior executives to overlook her race. The senior vice president for store operations had visited her store and others in the area and then sent an email back to headquarters that read: "African Americans dominate — huge issue." The African-American store manager was fired the following day (Wet Seal continues to insist that the store manager resigned; whatever the truth, I think we can all agree that the work environment was hostile.).

As I said, a trifecta.



Monday, November 19, 2012

Management vs Labor: Guess Who's Still Winning?

Remember Warren Buffett's comment about class warfare, that "there's been class warfare going on for the last 20 years, and my class has won"? (CNN interview, 30 Sept 2011)

Not only does his class have, as he called it, the nuclear bomb, but some of his fellow members are preparing to drop that bomb.

Salon magazine reported last week that a Florida owner of some 40 Denny's restaurants has announced that he will "cut workers' hours in advance of Obamacare's full implementation in January 2014."

Salon reporter Natasha Lennard wrote that a recent survey found that the Affordable Care Act is expected to raise large businesses' costs by approximately 4%. Metz reportedly considered adding a 5% surcharge to restaurant prices, but "has no plans to implement this idea."

Metz knows that his decision will "force my employees to go out and get a second job", but felt that he had "no choice."

I have several choices to suggest to him. Most aren't printable.

To be fair to Denny's, Metz is not Denny's. He owns 40 of their restaurants, but Denny's opened its 1,600th restaurant in September 2010. Franchisees must maintain certain standards if they wish to retain their franchises. Should Denny's corporate decide that Metz is risking Denny's good name, they will take action.

Sadly, Mr. Metz is not alone in his greed and insensitivity. Other restaurant chains, like Papa John's and Red Lobster, are increasingly turning to part-time workers to reduce their healthcare (and other) costs.

Labor and especially labor unions make attractive targets for blame, especially when they really aren't to blame.

Another example in recent news is Hostess Brands, makers of the (in)famous Twinkies, Sno-Balls, Cup Cakes, etc., filing for bankruptcy and closing its doors and laying off 18,500 employees, and blaming the intransigence of the Bakery, Confectionery, Tobacco Workers and Grain Millers International Union for the company's demise. If only those workers had accepted the 30% pay cut that the company had offered, we could all still be enjoying our Twinkies guilt-free. Sort of.

There's no mention of the fact that this is Hostess' second bankruptcy since 2009, nor that Hostess has not been making contractually-obligated pension contributions, nor that Hostess has been run by six CEOs in eight years, none of whom had bread or cake baking experience, nor that "despite their financial woes, the company’s CEO got a 300%  salary increase from $750,000 to $2,250,000, and other top executives received raises worth hundreds-of-thousands of dollars." (Reported by Politicus USA; full story, here)

It's time for a new labor movement. Where's Norma Rae when we need her?

Friday, November 16, 2012

Who's Responsible, the Corporation or the Executive?

Corporations have one big advantage over people: not only do they have, thanks to Citizens United, the right of free speech, but: it's really hard to put a corporation in jail.

Many of us have wished for corporate jails (as opposed to for-profit jails run by corporations), to which we could have sent, for example, the banks that nearly destroyed our entire economy. Alas, those don't exist, and it's extremely rare that individual executives get charged.

So I was interested but not particularly surprised to read yesterday that, as a followup to the horrific Deepwater Horizon explosion and oil spill two years in which eleven workers died, BP had finally agreed to plead guilty to numerous criminal charges and to pay more than $4 billion in fines and penalties over the next five years (article by Clifford Krauss and John Schwartz in yesterday's New York Times, here).

But what really caught my eye is that the Justice Department filed criminal charges against three BP executives in connection with the spill.

According to the Times report,
The government charged the top BP officers aboard the drilling rig, Robert Kaluza and Donald Vidrine, with manslaughter in connection with each man who died, contending that the officials were negligent in supervising tests to seal the well. 

Prosecutors also charged David Rainey, BP’s former vice president for exploration in the Gulf of Mexico, with obstruction of Congress and making false statements for understating the rate at which oil was spilling from the well.
Those charged are denying any wrongdoing.

Me, I'd want to charge BP's CEO, but that's just me.

Ironically, today's news included a report of an explosion and fire aboard another Gulf oil rig (Associated Press report, in the New York Times, here).  Thankfully, the rig was not producing at the time and there are no reports of oil leaking. No one was believed killed in the fire, although several had been seriously injured. At the time of the report, the Coast Guard was still searching for two missing workers.

Thursday, October 18, 2012

Deceptive Reviews on Yelp? How Could This Be?!?

More in the "shocked, shocked" category....

Earlier this year, I was inspired by a David Streitfeld story in the New York Times to write a post about all those "5-star" reviews littering the Internet (blog post here; Streitfeld's story, here). Mr. Streitfeld has done it again, with an article in today's Times about an attempt by Yelp to halt deceptive reviewing practices.

Yelp, an online hub for reviews of local businesses (dry cleaners, restaurants, jewelry stores, you name it), realized that it had a problem with false reviews, and set up its own sting operation.
For every five new notices that are submitted, one is determined by internal filters to be so dubious — either highly favorable or highly critical — that it is banned to a secondary page, which few users bother with, instead of appearing on the business’s profile page. Many of the reviews tagged as fake are written by people new to Yelp.

As a result, some businesses have sought out Yelp's so-called "elite" reviewers -- those who have a track record of posting reviews -- and offered cash payments for positive reviews.

How do you find an "elite" reviewer? On Craigslist.

So a Yelp employee went to Craigslist itself, and posed as an elite reviewer.

The initial sting uncovered eight businesses ready to pay for excellent reviews. Which, given that Yelp has a reported 30 million reviews, doesn't sound like a lot. (A Yelp vice president is quoted as saying, "It is safe to say that this is just a sample" of businesses seeking to influence their status.)

Payments reportedly ranged from $5 to $200; reviewers were sometimes given boilerplate copy to post and sometimes asked to write their own (positive) copy.

For the next three months, the Yelp profile pages for those eight businesses will features a "consumer alert" that says, "We caught someone red-handed trying to buy reviews for this business."

This kind of public shaming may help, but I'm not convinced that it will make a real dent in the deceptions. A Cornell doctoral student in computer science who has been studying reviewer deception noted,
My intuition is that public shaming would increase the risk and therefore the cost of posting fake reviews, which could reduce the prevalence .... [But:] What’s to stop someone from going and soliciting fake positive reviews for a competitor’s restaurant, in order for them to be publicly shamed?

Let me reiterate my earlier closing:

Maybe we should rethink hive-mind reviews altogether. I have more confidence in the Times' restaurant reviews than in Yelp, and more confidence in what Consumer Reports says than in glowing reports on Amazon. Because even if I don't know those reviewers personally, I know what they stand for. 



Tuesday, October 9, 2012

Big Pharma, Little Compounding Pharmacy. It's Not That Simple.

I know that I've been following the ongoing story of a fungal meningitis outbreak closely because it could so easily have been me.

For those of you who haven't: To date (according to today's New York Times story by Denise Grady), eight people have died, 97 others have sickened, and as many as 13,000 may have been exposed to fungal meningitis, which has been traced to a tainted steriod given as a spinal injection for relief from back and neck pain. The medication in all cases was made by Massachusetts-based New England Compounding Center, which "has shut down, surrendered its license and recalled all its products, not just the steroid."

It is not yet known whether all the vials of the steriod were infected with fungus, or only some of them.

I had surgery several years ago to relieve back pain, and I'm among the lucky who have not (knock wood) had recurring problems. But one of the physicians I met before opting for surgery suggested that quarterly steriod injections could probably do the trick just as well. I was concerned about possible long-term effects of steroid use, hence the surgery. But, as I said, it could have been me.

How is it that so many people were exposed to this contaminated drug? How could it take so long to find out what happened? Why is it still not clear where all the drug went, and who received it? (The "13,000" figure I quote above is a "first estimate" from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.)

It turns out that
The Food and Drug Administration has more regulatory authority over a drug factory in China than over a compounding pharmacy in Massachusetts

according to a Boston University law professor, quoted in Saturday's Times, in an article by Denise Grady, Andrew Pollack, and Sabrina Tavernise. (Compounding pharmacies, the article explains, "mix up batches of drugs on their own, often for much lower prices than major manufacturers charge," and are increasingly used by some physicians and clinics to save money. Compounding pharmacies also sometimes fill "gaps left by shortages of drugs made by pharmaceutical companies.")

The problem is that 
Compounding falls in a legal no man’s land, between the federal government and the states. The F.D.A. regulates manufacturers, but compounders register as pharmacies, putting them under a patchwork of state rules. The F.D.A. did develop a clear set of rules for compounding, but subsequent litigation that culminated in a Supreme Court decision in 2002 struck them down, and Congress never re-established the agency’s clear authority...

Who knew? Well, somebody did, of course, but it was certainly news to me. And I might have been more trusting of a "compounding pharmacy" -- because that sounds more local and service-oriented -- than of a huge pharmaceutical company.

Not that all compounding pharmacies are that local (or, obviously, that service-oriented). New England Compounding was apparently licensed in all fifty states, and there are 23 states now tracking where this specific steroid went. A Washington lawyer, and a former chief counsel for the FDA, was quoted in Saturday's article as saying,
Some of these companies are just setting up big manufacturing shops in the guise of traditional compounding and making drugs that are, for the most part, commercially available. Instead of making fake Rolexes, they are making fake drugs.
If this is how industries self-regulate (and all too often, it is), is it any wonder that I keep asking for more regulation, not less?